The single most frequent feedback comment on referred CIPD coursework is: "Too descriptive — needs greater critical evaluation." Moving beyond descriptive summaries into postgraduate critical analysis is the key to unlocking distinction grades in CIPD Level 5 and CIPD Level 7 assignments.
Descriptive Writing vs Critical Writing: The Key Difference
| Descriptive Writing (Referral / Low Pass) | Critical Writing (Merit / Distinction Standard) |
|---|---|
| Explains WHAT an HR policy or theoretical framework is. | Critiques WHY it succeeds or fails under different organizational conditions. |
| Summarizes a single author's argument without challenge. | Contrasts competing scholarly viewpoints and synthesizes contradictory evidence. |
| Accepts HR tools at face value (e.g. "Performance appraisals motivate staff"). | Exposes underlying limitations and systemic biases (e.g. recency bias, cost vs ROI). |
The "What? So What? Now What?" Critical Framework
Structure your critical paragraphs using this proven 3-stage model (recommended in our 7-step assignment completion roadmap and executive report structure):
- 1. What? (15% of paragraph): Concisely state the concept or theoretical model with an accurate Harvard citation.
- 2. So What? (60% of paragraph): Critically interrogate the model. What are its contextual limitations? What do contrasting scholars argue? What empirical data exists?
- 3. Now What? (25% of paragraph): What are the strategic implications for the HR leader, business KPIs, and bottom line to satisfy your Assessment Criteria?
Distinction-Grade Critical Linking Phrases:
• "While [Author A] asserts that..., this perspective has been fundamentally challenged by [Author B], who demonstrates that..."
• "Although empirically robust in manufacturing contexts, the AMO model exhibits significant limitations when applied to decentralized gig-economy platforms because..."
• "Consequently, while the short-term ROI appears favorable, the long-term cultural attrition risk outweighs the initial cost savings..." (Avoids common assignment errors).
Want a Critical Analysis Review of Your Draft?
Our Chartered FCIPD assessors rewrite descriptive sections into high-impact critical evaluations.
Get Critical Writing ReviewChat with Writing Specialist
Have an assessor review your draft paragraph for critical analysis depth.
Chat on WhatsApp